Wednesday, May 02, 2007

BOUNCIN'

I've been listening to a lot of music from about ten years ago. Kind of unpredictably, I've gotten back into jam rock supergroup PHISH. I have been downloading many shows from www.momadance.com and enjoying them very much. My tattooed punk girlfriend refuses to hear about how DIY and great Phish are, how they are so DIY that they only play guitars made by their neighbor from Vermont, how they give all their profits from Phish Food ice cream to charity, how they have a great sense of humor, and how they became huge without any mainstream radio or pop culture support. Actually, I don't think any of my friends want to hear about how great Phish is. So, here is a performance of Phish's biggest "hit" - hated by all mid nineties Phishheads as the ultimate "newbie" song, only suitable for bathroom breaks mid set:

Bouncin Round The Room, performed in 1990

Maybe it's how I don't want to talk about politics any more and have a boring job that Phish's music calms me for. Maybe it was seeing the Phish tribute band Phix play last year. Maybe it's that I'm getting old and I actually saw Phish shows over the summer every summer from 1997 to 2000. I don't know.

My favorite Phish song of right now is "Punch You In The Eye". Look it up.

For the punkers out there I've been downloading all these tracks and loving them too:
One guy's history of Emo from the 1990s to 2000s:
http://www.canyouseethesunset.com/2007/04/spoonful-of-emo-revisited.html

My favorite song from this collection right now is Jejune's song from the split with Jimmy Eat World. I'm totally ripping off stuff like that and Unrest for our band Apples of the Earth.

2 comments:

Zachary Dietl said...

For a given band, X is the number of members in the band while N is the amount of equipment they own (defined as units, one amp, one speaker, one piece of drum set, etc). Dividing N/X gives you their gear quotient.

Now, the gear quotient represents an ideal mean between not having enough gear (not being able to produce enough sounds) and having too much gear (producing too many sounds and making a big mess.) We can take a few example bands and plug in the numbers.

On the low end we have "Bug Eyed Mind" from Providence Rhode Island. X = 1, while N = 2 (a synthesizer and an amp.) gq = N/X, so 2 = 2/1.

In the mid range we have the castawaves. 2 members, 2 symbols, 1 bass drum, 3 toms, 1 snare, 1 guitar, 1 amp, 2 microphones. N = 11, X = 2. gq = 4.5 .

In the high range we can use Phish. I don't know what N is, because trey has like ten guitars and the drum set is the size of a car. assume N = around 50. For four guys in the band, the gq = 12.5 .

When it comes to interpreting the data, there are a few important qualifiers. First of all, what kind of music do they play? A punk band needs way less equipment than a prog rock band. We can create a value system for how much gear you need by genre; genre value = V

Punk = 1
Twee = 1
Surf Rock= 1
Pop = 2
Classic Rock = 3
Techno/electronic = 2
Jam Band = 3
Jazz = 2
Prog Rock = 5
Noise = 2

we can then add to our original formula gq = (N/X) - V. Bug Sized Mind's new gq = 0. Castawaves = 3.5 . Phish = 9.5.

We now have a modified gear quotient. Bug Sized Mind isn't trying hard enough and gets a zero. The Castawaves have a healthy 3.5, while Phish's high number suggests that they don't need all that gear on stage to do what they do. But another important qualifier is that Phish isn't using all of their gear at one time; the sound is much more economic than that. We can subtract another two points for this, giving them a 7.5. Still a little high, but not too bad.

Ultimately the GQ is not a "good" or "bad" rating for a band. But it is a general indicator of that band's attitude towards music making, and reasonable litmus test for what a band's fans look for when others make music. I tend to prefer bands who's GQ is between 2 and 5. Mike Castawave likes more music than I do and his range between 2 and 10.

Anonymous said...

i am not a punk. you take that back.